Senators hear testimony about BSDC

Friday, Aug 22, 2008 - 09:48:56 am CDT

The Associated Press

 Sandra Ham panicked earlier this year when she heard the U.S. Department of Justice found abuse and neglect at the Beatrice State Developmental Center, where her 23-year-old son has lived for six years.

But after she made some calls and did some research, the Lincoln woman is convinced the center is the best place for her son, Ian, who is autistic and struggled in group homes for 3 1/2 years before he moved to the center.

Ham testified Thursday in Lincoln before a legislative committee set up to investigate problems at the hospital, which is home to 267 developmentally disabled people.

The Justice Department investigation uncovered about 200 cases of alleged neglect and abuse at the hospital from late 2006 to late 2007. More than half of the cases have been substantiated.

Federal investigators discovered allegations that staff members shoved patients, called them names and played demeaning games. Staff members reportedly slept during shifts, leaving patients in clothing soaked with urine.

A former resident, 60-year-old Nancy Webb, told senators she lived at the Beatrice center from age 5 to 27 and was treated badly. Webb said she was spanked, wasn’t paid for work and lived in a dormitory with 20 other women. Now, 30 years later, she lives with a family in Omaha, has friends and works at a kennel caring for dogs.

“I don’t want to ever go back to Beatrice again,” Webb said. “Beatrice is not a good place for anyone.”

In June, the state agreed to a settlement with the Justice Department that helped Nebraska avoid prosecution or financial penalties. The state Department of Health and Human Services agreed to several measures to improve service at the center. An independent expert will make regular visits to verify conditions are improving.

The state is trying to move people into community-based programs to help relieve staffing problems, and some patient advocates want the center closed altogether.

Ham and other guardians of patients object strenuously, saying their children and siblings can’t be cared for by community-based services.

But Patty McGill Smith told senators guardians opposed to the center closing are dealing with a host of emotions, including worries about whether they made the right decision by placing their family members at the center.

McGill Smith, whose 38-year-old daughter Jane is autistic, is past president of The Arc of Nebraska, which works with people who have developmental disabilities.

The Beatrice center has likely offered a place of hope for family members desperate for help, she said.

But times have changed, McGill Smith said, and it’s time to stop institutionalizing people.

McGill Smith shares an Omaha house with her daughter, who receives services there.

Committee Chairman Sen. Steve Lathrop of Omaha said he’s not convinced there’s no place for the Beatrice center.

“There are some people that are at such a safety risk that we cannot find a place in the community for them,” he told McGill Smith.

A committee report, due back to the Legislature in December, is expected to lead to legislation that would address problems at Beatrice and the broader challenge of serving developmentally disabled people.

Leave a Comment

All posts are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.

Log in to submit comment or Create New Account below

*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

*First Name:
*Last Name:
*Zip Code:
By submitting this form you agree with our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Please check this box to confirm:
 
Jane Doe Employee
Aug 22, 2008 10:22 AM
I have worked at BSDC for the past 4 years. I directly work with the individuals and LOVE it!! They are the most awesome people and its a joy everyday to be included in their lives. I think what everyone needs to understand is that the problems at BSDC are not directly related to the individuals living there OR the staff that directly works with they day in and day out. It's the upper management that needs to be straightened out. The staff that works on the living units simply follow the orders given to us from "up above" in A Building. We do our utmost to care for the individuals. The staffing situation is holding us back however. Because of the bad press lately few people want to be associated with BSDC. However, they are only hearing the bad stuff. They don't hear from the parents and guardians that WANT their son, daughter, or relative to remain there because they believe they're getting excellent care at the facility. The men and women that live there get opportunities to go out to the movies, zoo, and pretty much wherever they have a desire to go but because staffing is minimal a lot of times we are unable to do so. Everyday that I work there I know I'm helping in someone's life. Working there you become very close to the men or women on the home and to some you become like family. It's really pains me to think that they are going to send a lot of the individuals out to group homes or other places where they wont know anyone and are unfamiliar. A lot of the people out there have lived there most of their lives and a change like that would uproot everything they know and are used to. I do believe there are those out there that could benefit from being placed in a group home and for those individuals I'm all for it. But to move someone out to a completely different environment just to make the numbers look good on campus makes me sick. I hope there can be a happy medium found for the sake of the men and women that thrive there.
girlfromhope
Aug 22, 2008 10:53 AM
Again, we are hearing of abuse and neglect at BSDC. The lady said 30 years ago she was spanked and lived in a dormitory with 20 other women. I worked there 30 years ago and it is unbelievable the progress that BSDC has made. It is a great facility with very caring staff and the individuals really get great care. The abuse and neglect allegations are a farce at best! I am not saying that there has never been cases of abuse, but back 30 years ago there were not the sophisticated meds we have now that actually address the issues the individuals have. Back then, we did the very best we could to keep all of the individuals safe and cared for. Now, the units are clean, the individuals are well taken care of, and it is a great place for individuals that need that type of care. You noticed, the woman said she was spanked, not beaten, there is a difference!
Former Employee
Aug 22, 2008 11:23 AM
This article is a little skewed, isn't it? The Lincoln Journal Star has a more balanced article written and I would encourage readers to surf over to their site and read it!

In the LJS article there are quotes of parents who have had children in community based programs and have had terrible experiences and have found BSDC to be the best place for their child. This article doesn't mention the specifics of those parents's testimony, maybe because it points out that the community based programs suffer from the same problems as BSDC does?

The parents even called for the same scrutiny of the community based programs as is given to BSDC, but that's not mentioned either. No matter what the program they are administered by human beings and human beings are flawed creatures so no program will ever be operated flawlessly. Currently the flaws at BSDC are being focused on because they are being heavily investigated - if the same scrutiny was given to the community based programs the same flaws would be shown (because they get their employees from the human race too!), but currently they are not heavily examined because it's not economically productive to do so - one auditor at BSDC covers a whole lot more residents and staff than one at a community based program, so they opt for more bang for their buck and focus on the institutions and ignore the community based. A sad fact, but a fact none the less.

Bringing in a former BSDC resident who has not resided there for THRITY YEARS doesn't make much sense either when we're trying to evaluate the current status of the institution, does it? Besdies, we don't know the story - maybe her time at the facility actually prepared her for her eventual re-integration into society and has helped her succeed? Just because she didn't enjoy her time there doesn't mean it was not a positive thing - I didn't enjoy my time in the service either, but it has helped me to succeed today.

If one checks into what community based programs many of the more severly handicapped are being moved into they'll find they are going to nursing homes! Nursing homes are caring places too, but they can only provide the basic care, they are not equipped to provide the specialized developmental treatment that many of the most severly disabled require so we are basically just warehousing them like we did years ago but we're hiding them in several nursing homes rather than having them all in one spot - that's progress???

The fact is that there is no one treatment model that will serve the needs of all those who are handicapped. There is a place for community based programs but there is also a place for a more institutional program also, as well as many others that combine elemonts of both.

Mistakes are made, abuses happen - but they happen no matter what the program is because the employees come from the human race. A sad fact, but it's reality. There are bad police officers, bad counselors, bad youth leaders, bad teachers, inept medical professionals (doctors just bury their mistakes!), etc.. NO program, including community based ARC supported programs, will ever be administered perfectly (but we should always strive to do so!). Currently BSDC is simply being held to a standard of nothing less than perfection and the community based programs are being ignored so BSDC looks terrible and the others look great, but it's just an illusion and unfortunately far too many are falling for it and the least fortunate in our society are going to pay the price as they are forced to move into these less supervised community programs.

Please Daily Sun, try to choose articles that give more balance in the future!
Bugz
Aug 22, 2008 11:55 AM
How many handicapped people can one community absorb? With BSDC, Mosaic, and community based homes saturating the community I am sure that at least 1/3 of Beatrice is mentally or physically handicapped in some way. Many are financial burdens on our school system, at times requiring one on one with teachers. At some point we have to say enough is enough! We just can't afford it!
Outsider
Aug 22, 2008 12:58 PM
I am looking to moving to Nebraska in the near future and am currently in the MRDD field. I would like to give a thanks to all of the hard working staff who have stuck it out at BSDC. It is hard work and you always have to remember to keep the individuals living there in your first thoughts. It will get better if your hearts are in the right place!
staff
Aug 22, 2008 5:54 PM
Why is someone who hasn't lived at BSDC allowed to say anything about BSDC, and that fact that things have changed in 30 years! How do we know this person wasn't coerced into saying bad things? This is ridiculous!
System is broken
Aug 23, 2008 8:50 AM
HHS in nebraska is so broken that they cant handle foster care, the elderly, or developmentally disabled people. They have nowhere for these people to go to so they are shipping them to nursing homes where the staff arent able to provide proper care because they are misplaced. Our Governor needs to get off his tushy and address this agency which needs house cleaning from the top down!!!! How is staff supposed to fix what is a paper nightmare that does nothing but fill pockets for too many administrators!!! Nothing will change until johanns croneys are gone.
sa
Aug 25, 2008 12:59 PM
how pathetic, someone who has not lived BSDC for 30 years has no idea how much it has changed. And did she just say this to be dramatic. It happens you know. Most will say what they are wanted to say. This is laughable that a person who has not been there for 30 years was asked questions, it isnt even close to the same place it was then.
Story Photo
Patricia McGill Smith, immediate past president of The ARC of Nebraska, testifies at the State Capitol in Lincoln, Neb. Thursday, Aug. 21, 2008, before a special legislative committee created to investigate problems with developmentally disabled patients at the Beatrice State Developmental Center. (AP Photo/Bill Wolf)
Text Size:
Text Size Increase Text Size Decrease
Print Story Email Story
BSDC hearing in Beatrice Friday


Employees and former employees of the Beatrice State Developmental Center are expected to testify at a hearing at 9 a.m. Friday at the center. Read the Saturday Daily Sun for coverage.

Calendar of Events

December 2008
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
Today's Events